The Great Famine-Genocide in Soviet Ukraine (Holodomor)

  back    
A PROPER MEMORIAL, EDITORIAL
  

The Ukrainian Weekly
Sunday, December 8, 2002

 

It is inexcusable that Kyiv lacks a proper memorial to the victims of the Great Famine, the artificially induced mass starvation that took the lives of 7 million to 10 million Ukrainians in 1932-1933. We welcome the recent announcement by the Ukrainian World Congress that it would erect a suitable monument in Kyiv in time for its gathering in Kyiv next August. Yet we believe that the time has come to develop a broader plan and vision.

Seventy years after Stalin and the Soviet regime eradicated a good portion of the Ukrainian population, the world knows little of what occurred and how the nation suffered. Few governments officially recognize that such a tragic event took place, much less label it the genocide that it was. Even in Ukraine most schoolchildren do not know what happened during those years of Stalin's terror.

A commentary appearing in the English-language newspaper Kyiv Post, written by Morgan Williams, a public relations professional living in Kyiv, suggests a broader approach to a memorial to the Great Famine. He believes Ukraine needs an educational and research center in the heart of the country's capital.

Citing the lack of knowledge on the man-made cataclysm of 1932- 933, Mr. Williams, states: "The basic plan should, therefore, include the construction of adequate facilities for research, documentation, education and study, including a library and museum. Such a facility would create, for the first time in Ukraine, a suitable venue for scholarly research into the Famine-Genocide and other crimes of communism."

Mr. Williams suggest taking the idea for a memorial and expanding it to include a complex of facilities in the center of Kyiv. He states that the project for a proper Great Famine memorial in Kyiv could be pushed back from a deadline of next year to 2008, which would allow sufficient time to plan the project, gather the funds and build the facility. It would also allow for a memorial complex to open on the 75th anniversary of the tragedy.

We believe this to be not only a superb idea, but one that is long overdue. A research and education center would provide those researchers who have investigated the Great Famine with a facility to continue their work. Such a center would also allow for a concentration of material and energy, a critical mass of information and documentation that would become an effective counterpoint to those who would continue to maintain that no Great Famine ever existed or if it did it was either a natural calamity or the result of human error in establishing a collective farm infrastructure.

While it is obvious that such a center would be an expensive proposition, the Great Famine is a historical event of such magnitude that we must do whatever it takes to preserve its memory and enter it into the world's historical record.

While it is open to question as to what degree current state and government authorities in Ukraine would actively support and fund such an undertaking, we duly note here that in the past they found sufficient funds in the state budget for such grandiose, and worthy, projects such as the rebuilding of St. Michael's Golden- Domed Sober and the Dormition Sobor in the Monastery of the Caves complex.

Yet the government need not be the single or even primary source of the funding for such an undertaking. Many in our diaspora have backed away from financial support for Ukraine in light of the financial abuses and corruption that have marked Ukraine's difficult transformation into a European society. Contribution to a research and education center on the Great Famine would give many of us a way to reignite our efforts on behalf of Ukraine and our great nation.

We believe that a Famine Center in Kyiv is a project worthy of the Ukrainian World Congress. The idea deserves serious consideration by the UWC and a public debate within our diaspora on how it might develop.


EDITORIAL, The Ukrainian Weekly, December 8, 2002
Editor-in-chief: Roma Hadzewycz
Published by the Ukrainian National Association, Inc.
2200 Route 10, P.O. Box 280, Parsippany, NJ 07054
973 292 9800, FAX 973 644 9510
http://www.ukrweekly.com
For personal and academic use only


NOTE: You will find below the commentary mentioned in the above editorial which appeared in the English-language newspaper Kyiv Post, Kyiv, Ukraine, November 28, 2002, written by Morgan Williams:

A FAMINE MONUMENT IS NOT ENOUGH

Plans for the commemoration of the 70th anniversary of the Great Famine should be expanded to include construction of an educational and research center, Morgan Williams argues

By Morgan Williams
Category: OPINION
The Kyiv Post, Kyiv, Ukraine
November 28, 2002
http://www.kpnews.com/main/12378

 

The Ukrainian World Congress announced on Sept. 27 that it had "decided to honor the memory of the millions of victims of the Great Famine in Ukraine 1932-1933 by erecting in the name of all Ukrainians who live around the world (the Diaspora) a suitable monument in the city of Kyiv."

The UWC said the 70th anniversary of the famine should be marked by construction of a monument that would be dedicated during the Seventh World Congress of Ukrainians in Kyiv during August 2003. It also called upon the Ukrainian and other governments to recognize the famine as an act of genocide against the Ukrainian people and to condemn the perpetrators.

The country is unquestionably in need of such a monument. It would quickly become known and recognized around the world, and would serve as a potent symbol of the terrible crimes committed against Ukraine and her people and of the hope that such crimes will never be repeated.

The program to build such a monument is welcome, but it is important to consider the larger picture and the totality of needs that exist in Ukraine today. Scholars who have studied the great famine and related issues insist that much more than just a new monument is needed. Those working on the great famine in Ukraine have said that construction of an educational and research center is the first priority and should be included in any plans to honor the memory of the famine victims.

"The enforced famine of 1932-1933, engineered by the Soviet regime in which 7 million to 10 million Ukrainians perished, qualifies as one of the most massive genocides the world has ever seen and as one of the most heinous mass crimes ever committed by man against man," the UWC said.

Prior to 1990, the majority of research on the famine had to take place outside Ukraine. It is now high time for domestic scholars and researchers to document the crimes of communism from within Ukraine. The resources made available to the Association of Famine Researchers of Ukraine and other worthy organizations for their work over the past 11 years have been totally inadequate. Considering the importance of these issues, the meager resources allocated have been an embarrassment. There is work that urgently needs to be done now before the last of those survivors who have personal knowledge of the famine die. This work cannot be done without more support.

The basic plan should, therefore, include the construction of adequate facilities for research, documentation, education and study, including a library and museum. Such a facility would create, for the first time in Ukraine, a suitable venue for scholarly research into the famine-genocide and other crimes of communism.

The UWC is being asked by many in Ukraine to consider extending its program from a one-year to a six-year initiative. It would thus be completed in time for the 75th anniversary of the great famine in the fall of 2008. Such an extended program, involving a variety of organizations, businesses and leaders in Ukraine and around the world, could raise the funds necessary to build the proposed monument and the educational and research complex.

If such a major historical project is undertaken over the next six years, the UWC should take into account the following considerations:

    A very central, important and visible location should be found and offered by the city of Kyiv. The UWC should not settle for anything less.

    The location selected in Kyiv should be large enough to allow for the construction of the monument and also the construction of the research, education, library and museum center over a five- to six-year period.

    The design of the sculpture-monument and the educational complex must be world-class with a creative and inspiring design. The sculpture cannot be allowed to be as mediocre and disappointing as some of those raised in Kyiv in recent years. The complex must be "for the ages," and must honor appropriately the famine victims.

    Adequate funds must be committed for building the monument and the educational complex. The UWC should state that it is prepared to raise, in cooperation with a variety of governmental and private organizations, including those from Ukraine, whatever it takes to fulfill the program.

The UWC is to be congratulated for its drive to have the famine recognized as genocide and to build a new monument. The UWC should indeed lead this project. But while the UWC should certainly focus on the Ukrainian Diaspora for support and help in raising the necessary funds, it should also open their program to include selected individuals in Ukraine who have studied these historical issues, representatives of leading Ukrainian organizations and businesses, and government leaders. The UWC should also include those individuals, organizations and businesses around the world that have shown they are friends of Ukraine and that want to participate and provide support. Participation should not be limited to those of Ukrainian heritage.

The UWC may also wish to consider including in the 70th to 75th-anniversary program annual food drives that would raise a large quantity of food and funds. Unfortunately, political famines still occur today, 70 years after Stalin used an artificial famine as a tool in his overall plan to crush the people, culture and spirit of Ukraine. The food and funds collected would be distributed to those around the world who are starving due to the policies of inept and corrupt governments that continue to engage in repression, murder and genocidal actions to achieve their goals.

A program like that outlined above, when completed, would be a major step in the long effort to ensure that the million of victims of the 1932-1933 famine-genocide and the many other repressions against Ukraine and her people over a long period did not die in vain.


A business, government and public affairs consultant, Morgan Williams is the president of the Ukraine Market Reform Group. He is also publisher of the ArtUkraine.com Web site and the ArtUkraine.com Information Service. He has been involved in Ukraine economic development issues for 10 years.


OPINION: The Kyiv Post, Kyiv, Ukraine, November 28, 2002
http://www.kpnews.com/main/12378
For personal and academic use only
 
 

  back