The Great Famine-Genocide in Soviet Ukraine (Holodomor)


The Black Earth and Ukraine Areas Are in Better Shape Than Reported


Present Effort to Get Land Sown Will be Paralleled by Greater Harvest Drive


Wireless to The New York Times


ODESSA, Russia, April 26 (By Mail to Paris)---Autumn-sown grain in the Central Black Earth region and the Ukraine wintered better and is in better shape than is generally realized in Moscow. This the writer can confirm, not only from visual evidence from a train, but from conversations with all sorts of persons, from officials to peasants traveling in "hard" coaches.

Spring work has been temporarily delayed by heavy rains, but the food situation is undoubtedly better than has been reported. In Moscow the writer was told on seemingly good authority that a bucket of potato peelings brought 15 rubles in and around Kiev. This Kiev officials indignantly denied.

Peasants Offer Chickens

At any rate, at the station of Konotop, only a few hours from Kiev, peasant women offered roast chicken at 20 rubles each and did not find buyers, because the travelers, mostly local persons, said the price was too high.

It is an old story, which the writer first heard on the Volga during the famine in the Summer of 1921. Everywhere they said, "Things here are desperate, and unless we get relief we will die before Christmas"--which was true enough.

Then we asked them, "But are people dying here now?" And they replied, "No, not here yet, but if you go to the village of So-and-So you will find hardly any one alive." We went to said village and heard exactly the same story, "Here we are desperate, thought not yet dying, but at So-and-So conditions are frightful."

In Odessa the bread ration has actually been increased in recent weeks from 400 to 500 grams (500 grams equals 1.1 pounds), and though conditions are terribly hard there is no sign of real famine conditions or that people are dying in the streets, as is reported in Moscow. The mortality figures jumped during the Winter, and there is a good deal of typhus, always a concomitant of undernourishment in Russia, but it is not epidemic, a fact that is confirmed by resident foreigners.

The writer talked to peasants at the covered city market who had taken advantage of the lull in the sowing campaign to sell eggs and a few early vegetables, and he got the same impression of a change in attitude as was asserted by a Communist leader at Kiev. The peasant, whether collectivized or individualists, seem to feel an end has been made of the muddle and mismanagement of the past two years, and that Moscow is taking an interest in them.

Peasants Regain Hope

In short, the peasants believe the centre of gravity, as far as the Kremlin is concerned, has shifted back from industry to agriculture. This belief, which is entirely true, is one of the most important features of the present situation in the Soviet Union.

It is significant that local newspapers of Odessa, Kiev and other Ukrainian towns along the railroad all report a large new influx of individual peasants into the collectives, which is confirmed here not only by a member of the Presiding Council of the Odessa Provincial Government, but by peasants with whom the writer has talked.

On the other hand, it must be remembered that these peasants are so to speak, "in good standing." and there is no doubt that thousands of competent farmers---tens and hundreds of thousands if this whole Soviet Union is taken into consideration---have been dispossessed as kulaks and sent into exile or left to gain a living in construction camps as best they can.

In all too many cases their land and cattle fell into incompetent or deliberately dishonest hands and were shamefully mismanaged. Even such a fleeting glimpse of the country as one gets from a train revealed all too many animals in shockingly poor condition and all too few calves in such meager herds as are now grazing on what used to be the richest section of Russian soil.

The shortage of animal traction and meat will be felt for the next five years at least, and the present tremendous effort to get the land plowed and sown must be paralleled by a yet greater effort later to get the crop harvested.

The New York Times, Sunday, May 14, 1933